Showing posts with label Karen Pyror. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Karen Pyror. Show all posts

Friday, January 6, 2012

BUYER BEWARE: There is no such thing as a certified animal behavioralist

Ginger and Opal

BUYER BEWARE: There is no such thing as a certified animal behavioralist!


Author, Cindy Ludwig

There is no such thing as a "Certified Animal Behavioralist." If someone claims to be a
behaviorist (not "behavioralist" - big telltale sign right there in the spelling), ask specifically what degree they have and what specific certification they have as well as the granting organization!

There are board-certified veterinary behaviorists (veterinarians with specialized training and
certification in behavior) and their credential is the DACVB (Diplomate of the American College
of Veterinary Behaviorists), applied animal behaviorists (CAAB) with the Animal Behavior Society (individuals with advanced degrees and professional certification) and now CCPDT
(Certification Council for Professional Dog Trainers) certified animal behaviorists (CBCC-KA -
certified behavior consultant canine - knowledge assessed) and Veterinary
Technician specialists (VTS) who specialize in and are certified in behavior by the AVBT
(Academy of Veterinary Behavior Technicians).

There are a few other organizations granting certification in canine behavior such as the
Association of Companion Animal Behavior Consultants (CBC - Certified Canine Behavior Consultant)
to individuals who have an advanced degree, at least 24 credit hours in behavior and additional
required coursework in psychology, counseling and statistics.

The International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants (IAABC) certifies individuals
as a CABC (Certified Animal Behavior Consultant) with a minimum of a high school diploma
and at least 3 years and 1000 hours in animal behavior consulting plus 400 hours of education and training

The Association for the Study of Animal Behavior (ASAB) in the UK certifies animal behaviorists with advanced education and extensive clinical experience as Clinical Animal Behaviorists.

A real animal behaviorist will, I hope, know what they are - a behaviorist, not a "behavioralist." The
fact that someone purports to be a" behavioralist" suggests to me this person does not even know the correct terminology! Remember, anyone can call him or herself a "behaviorist." Check out the individual's credentials - and remember, not all certifying bodies have the same standards! Beware - there are people out there calling themselves "behaviorists"
who are giving out bad advice!

Cindy Ludwig, M.A., KPA-CTP
(Master of Arts in Education, Karen Pryor Academy Certified Training Partner)
Owner, Canine Connection LLC
Website: www.dubuquedogtraining.com

Cindy Ludwig is a Karen Pryor Academy Certified Training Partner and owner of Canine Connection
LLC in Dubuque, Iowa (www.dubuquedogtraining.com). She is a member of the Association of Pet
Dog Trainers and the International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants.











Sunday, October 16, 2011

The Different Theories of Training Explained


Author, Cindy Ludwig
 
 
There are as many ways to train a dog as there are people who train them. There are television shows about dog training and blogs, books and a variety of training equipment for sale in pet stores. How does the average pet owner
who just wants a well behaved dog go about sorting through all this information
to determine which equipment and methods of training are the ones he should
choose for his dog? Do different dogs require different methods of
training?

Training methods exist on a continuum

The way I see it, dog training philosophy and methodology exist on a continuum
between hypothetical endpoints of reward-based training and correction-based
training. In reality, there is no such thing as reward-based training without
punishment (correction) because reward-based (aka “positive”) trainers withhold rewards which is a form of punishment, and there is no such thing as correction-based training without rewards since even correction-based trainers give some positive reinforcement (praise, food treats, etc.). Most trainers then lie somewhere on the continuum between the two endpoints, tending to be either reward-based or correction-based, depending on where they sit on the continuum.

Balanced training

The trainers that occupy the middle ground sometimes refer to themselves as
“balanced” trainers, using a “balance” of correction and rewards. If one imagines the reward-based end of the continuum as positive and the correction-based end of the continuum as negative, balanced training that hovers around the midpoint of zero could be conceived as having little or no effect, with the negative cancelling out the positive. In reality the result is more of a diminutive and unreliable response than an actual zero effect.

While it is totally possible to get a well behaved dog using this approach, the
trade-off is likely to be a dog that is inhibited and does not offer behaviors
for fear of being punished. Think about it, if you don’t know whether your next
move will be rewarded or punished, how likely are you to experiment and offer
new behaviors? What will your demeanor look like? Will you be very creative?
Have much initiative?

Is correction necessary to train dogs?

Many people who are not familiar with the science behind reward-based (aka “positive reinforcement”) training wonder how an animal can learn if not corrected. I think the question is not, how can you teach a dog without correction, but how can you teach a dog with it, the operative word being teach? We know, for example that stress inhibits learning and we also know that we learn more from our successes than our failures (MIT, 2009). The use of punishment – or correction in training in my opinion is really something that has its origin in outdated cultural norms.

So then, how does an animal learn what he did wrong if not corrected?

Quite simply. The basic premise of positive reinforcement training is that animals repeat what is rewarding and do not repeat what is not rewarding. So rather than correct or punish an animal for an undesired behavior, positive reinforcement trainers simply ignore unwanted behaviors and continually revise their training plan to set an animal up for success while observing for desirable responses on which to build their goal behaviors. Desired behaviors grow
stronger and undesired behaviors extinguish or go away. A motivated animal learns very quickly what works and what doesn’t to get him what he wants! For dog and handler, it’s a win-win situation!

Food

Some wonder if an animal trained with food rewards will always need food to continue to perform a desired behavior and the answer is yes and no – depends how you use it. Once a behavior is learned, the rate
of reinforcement (rewards) is decreased and put on a variable schedule, meaning the animal doesn’t get a reward for every correct behavior but instead receives rewards on a less frequent and irregular basis, which actually serves to keep the learned behaviors strong.

Skilled trainers know how to use food appropriately in training so that an animal is neither distracted by the presence of food or dependent on the food to perform.

Some people would like to train their dogs without food for a variety of reasons,
but food is a necessary part of animal training, at least in the early stages. It is what behaviorists call a primary reinforcer, meaning it is
something that all animals need and do not have to learn to like that serves to
increase the likelihood a behavior will be repeated.

Food can be delivered at the reinforcement rate necessary to facilitate learning and keep an animal engaged in the training process. Later on in the training
process, food will be systematically replaced with secondary reinforcers such as play, petting and praise.

Food is also integral to treating animals with fear and anxiety because food
activates the parasympathetic nervous system, causing an animal to relax and
develop what we call a positive emotional response. In training food is also
useful as a gauge of stress. An animal that cannot eat is too stressed to learn, and something needs to change before asking the animal to continue with a training session.

Where people get into trouble is using food as a bribe
rather than a reward. If we do too much luring with food and food
is always within easy view of the animal, the animal may become dependent on
food and refuse to perform without it. If instead, we keep the food out of sight and make rewards contingent on performance, food is used as a reward.

Clicker training

Clicker trainers are positive reinforcement trainers who minimize luring with food and use a small mechanical device called a clicker to signal to the animal being trained when it has performed a behavior worthy of a reward. The click-click sound of the clicker marks a behavior at a precise moment in time and signals to the animal that a reward is forthcoming for that behavior.

In clicker training there is no “wrong” or “no,” only right or try again! In
clicker training we speak of cues versus commands. In compulsion training, commands are given. In clicker training we teach a behavior
before teaching the animal the name (“cue”) of the behavior, whereas in
compulsion training and some other forms of positive reinforcement training the
command is taught at the same time a behavior is taught. A cue represents an opportunity for reinforcement, whereas a command is an order. If you give a
command and your dog disobeys your only option is to increase the forcefulness of your command, but if you cue your dog to perform a certain behavior and he misses it the first time, you’d better believe he will listen better the next time!


The benefits of clicker training include 1) no harmful effects, even if used
incorrectly, 2) rapid learning, 3) enthusiasm for learning, 4) deepened bond
between owner/trainer and his or her animal, and 4) long term memory for what
has been learned.


“Clicker training” is a highly precise and versatile method of training that can be used to teach almost any animal anything the animal is physically able to do. It is used in a variety of settings these days from zoos to wildlife preserves to veterinary offices to guide dog training centers such as Guide Dogs for the Blind on the west coast. Clicker training can be used to teach scent
detection dogs, to teach canine musical freestyle, and to teach agility to
cats, horses, rabbits and sheep! It has even been used to teach rats to sniff
out land mines! Now it is available for dog owners to use with their pets!

Clicker training encourages creativity and teaches an animal how to learn. Clicker trained animals are easy to spot –they’re enthusiastic learners with happy faces and bright eyes! When not working, they’re calm and content,
but ready to start their next training session when the opportunity arises.

Lure-reward training

Lure-reward trainers are generally positive reinforcement trainers who use food as a lure moreso than clicker trainers and may or may not use a clicker or other marker signal in training. Lure-reward trainers vary greatly in their methodology and may employ some degree of correction.

Correction-based training

In stark contrast to positive reinforcement training is correction-based training,
aka compulsion, or force-based training. Correction-based trainers believe they must correct or punish undesired behaviors in order for an animal to learn.


Correction-based trainers use such training aids as prong (“pinch”) collars, choke chain collars and shock collars, aka “remote trainers” or “e-collars.” All of these devices work by applying what is known in behavior science as positive
punishment
and negative reinforcement. Quite simply, an aversive stimulus is applied for an undesired behavior and it is discontinued when the animal complies with a desired behavior.

Positive reinforcement, negative reinforcement – what do all these terms mean?

Don’t get confused about the term, “positive punishment.” “Positive” in behavioral terms simply means to add something.
N
egative” means to take something away. “Positive reinforcement” means to add something that is reinforcing, and “reinforcement” is something which increases the likelihood a behavior will be repeated. “Positive punishment” means to add punishment, aka correction. “Punishment,” in behavioral terms means something which decreases the likelihood of a behavior being repeated.

“Negative reinforcement” is a little trickier – it means to remove something which will cause an animal to repeat a desired behavior. i.e., comply. Stopping electrical shock when an animal lies down or comes when called would be an example of negative reinforcement. Using a “force retrieve” by pinching a dog’s
ear or his toe until he takes a dumbbell in his mouth is another example of
negative reinforcement. The pain stops when the animal complies. Negative
reinforcement is a very powerful method of training, but it raises ethical
questions in the minds of positive reinforcement trainers who contend that we
have just as effective if not more effective means of training without the
unwanted effects of punishment, aka correction.

“Negative punishment” is yet another option for getting a dog to respond the way that we would like by manipulating consequences. In negative punishment, we are “punishing” the dog by removing something the dog desires, for example, our attention, in order to decrease the likelihood a behavior will be repeated. A good example of this is turning your back to your dog when he jumps on you for attention. If you turn your back consistently your dog will learn that jumping up doesn’t get him what he wants and this behavior will extinguish, or disappear. Positive trainers also teach the dog what to do instead of jumping, so they will reward the dog with attention when he sits or at least isn’t jumping. This is positive reinforcement.

So in summary, “positive reinforcement” trainers rely on positive reinforcement and negative punishment to train dogs and modify behavior. Correction-based (aka compulsion) and “balanced” trainers employ positive punishment and negative reinforcement whereas positive reinforcement trainers, particularly clicker trainers do not.

The vastly different paradigms of reward-based trainers and correction-based
trainers

The overarching difference between positive reinforcement (aka reward-based) trainers and correction or force-based trainers is where they place the locus of
control. Positive reinforcement trainers, especially clicker trainers work hard
to positively motivate and empower their animals to give them ample opportunity for success while correction-based trainers work to control their animals through external devices and the threat of punishment.

The problem with punishment

Positive reinforcement trainers recognize that the fallout from punishment can be harmful to their animal’s mental health, their relationship and the training
process. They know that for punishment to be effective it must meet a number of criteria:

·      It must be applied at the right intensity the first time and every time; otherwise the animal may get used to (“habituate” to) the pain and increasing levels are required to be effective
·      It must be applied consistently; otherwise it can actually have the unintended effect of strengthening the undesired behavior
·      It must be applied at the precise moment an undesired behavior occurs for the animal to make the intended association between the punishment and the undesired behavior

Punishment can result in:
·      Suppressed fearful or aggressive behavior and worsening of the animal’s underlying emotional state
·      An unintended association between the punishment and the punisher, another animal, object or situation
·      Physical harm due to electrical burns, trauma to the trachea, damage to the nerves of the eyes or life-threatening pulmonary edema (AVSAB, 2007)

In a recent study, investigators found that dogs whose owners managed aggression with confrontational techniques such as yelling, growling at the dog, hitting, kicking, grabbing the dog and shaking, physically forcing the dog down onto its side, physically forcing a dog to release something from its mouth, alpha rolls (physically rolling the dog onto its back and holding it there), or staring developed increased aggression. The researchers concluded that these maneuvers were “fear-eliciting and may lead to owner aggression.” (Univ. of PA, 2009)

Do we really need to show our dogs who’s boss?

It is a misconception derived from outdated information about wolf packs that we need to dominate our dogs and be their “pack leader.” We now know, based on the work of Dr. Ray Coppinger that dogs, although close relatives of the wolf, aren’t pack animals as we previously thought, but rather scavengers
that form loose associations with one another around food resources.


Of course all that has changed somewhat with selective breeding and integration into the human family unit. But one thing remains certain – dogs are dogs and humans are humans and we humans don’t do a very good job of imitating canines. Don’t think for a minute that your dog thinks you are his canine pack leader –
he recognizes you as a species apart from his own and tries very hard to
understand you as a human. We form a social unit with our pet dogs, but it is probably not best described as a “pack.”

Conclusion

If we give up the idea that we need to be the pack leader and dominate our canine companions, we should also be able to give up outdated training methods aimed at subduing them in favor of tools and techniques such as clicker training which bridge the communication gap and deepen our relationship.

While impeccable technique is no guarantee that correction-based training will have no untoward effects on our canine partners, the worst that can happen with amateur clicker trainers is that the dog gets a few ill-timed clicks and treats
and the bond between owner and dog is strenghtened.  Dog and human handler alike will still learn – and have fun doing it!

It is debatable whether correction-based or reward-based training works
faster. If punishment is applied absolutely correctly, it will stop undesired behavior without having to be repeated. But since punishment also inhibits learning, new behaviors may be acquired much more slowly, requiring far more repetition than with positive reinforcement training.


Positive reinforcement (reward-based) training is not only humane, but highly effective without side effects. It is founded on well established principles of behavior science. We know that this type of training is valid
and reliable because it works on virtually any animal and the same consistent
results can be replicated time and time again.


The choice of which training method to use really comes down to one simple
question. Do you want to make your dog obey using external control or do you want to motivate your dog through positive reinforcement of desired behaviors? If you want a partnership with your dog, a deeper relationship, if you want to develop an animal that thinks and is emotionally healthy, that is joyful and loves learning the choice is clear.


Training that rewards and builds on what a dog does right
rather than what he does wrong is not only a training philosophy, it is a way of life. Clicker trainers for example, use the same positive reinforcement methods with their human students as they do with their canine students. If you can relinquish control to gain it you will discover the wonderful world of positive reinforcement dog training and when you do, you will find that what you can accomplish with your dog is only limited by your imagination and what your dog is physically able to do!

Cindy Ludwig is a
Karen Pryor Academy Certified Training Partner and owner of Canine Connection
LLC in Dubuque, Iowa
www.dubuquedogtraining.com).  She is a member of the Association of Pet Dog Trainers and the International
Association of Animal Behavior Consultants.

References:

American
Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior – Behavior Professionals Statement
http://www.avsabonline.org/avsabonline/images/stories/Position_Statements/behavior%20professionals.pdf

American
Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior. (2008).
Position Statement on the Use of
Dominance Theory in Behavior Modification of Animals
. http://www.avsabonline.org/avsabonline/images/stories/Position_Statements/dominance%20statement.pdf

American
Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior. (2007) Position Statement: The Use of Punishment for Behavior Modification of
Animals.
http://www.avsabonline.org/avsabonline/images/stories/Position_Statements/Combined_Punishment_Statements.pdf

Coppinger, R., & Coppinger,
L. (2002). Dogs: A New Understanding of Canine Origin, Behavior,and Evolution.
New York:
Scribner.

Halber,
D. (2009). Why we learn more from our successes than our failures,
MIT News
Retrieved
from
http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2009/successes-0729.html

Herron, M.E. Shofer, F.S., & Reisner I.R. (2009).
Survey of the use and outcome of confrontational and non-confrontational
training methods in client-owned dogs showing undesired behaviors.
Applied Animal
Behaviour Science
117, 47–54
http://vet.osu.edu/assets/pdf/hospital/behavior/trainingArticle.pdf

Hiby, E.F., Rooney,
N.J.
, & Bradshaw, J.W.S.
Dog
training methods: their use, effectiveness and interaction with behaviour and
welfare
. Animal Welfare, 13
(1), 63-69(7).
http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/ufaw/aw/2004/00000013/00000001/art00010

Mech, L.D. (2008). What
ever happened to the term alpha wolf? International Wolf, 18 (4), 4-9.
http://www.wolf.org/wolves/news/pdf/winter2008.pdf

Open Letter
From Dr. Karen Overall regarding the use of shock collars. (2005).
http://www.joelwalton.com/shockcollars.html


Overall,
K.L.(2007). Why electric shock is not behavior modification. J. Vet. Behav.: Clin. Appl. Res. 2 (1),
1-4.
http://www.k9behavioralgenetics.net/resources/Articles/Why%20electric%20shock%20is%20not%20behavior%20modification.pdf

Polsky, R. (2000), Can aggression in dogs be
elicited through use of electronic pet containment systems? Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science,
3(4), 345-357


Pryor, K. (2002).The poisoned cue. http://www.clickertraining.com/node/164

Schilder,
M.B.H., van der Borg, J.A.M. (2004). Training dogs with the help of the shock
collar: Short and long term behavioural effects. Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. 85, 319-334
http://eldri.ust.is/media/ljosmyndir/dyralif/Trainingdogswithshockcollar.pdf

Resources:
American College of Veterinary Behaviorists. How to select a trainer – for owners. http://www.dacvb.org/resources/for-the-public/

APOPO:
Detection Rats Technology
http://www.apopo.org/home.php

Association
of Pet Dog Trainers: Trainer Certifications: What Do All Those Letters After
Everyone's Names Mean?
http://www.apdt.com/petowners/choose/certifications.aspx

Association of Pet Dog Trainers – Trainer Search. http://www.apdt.com/petowners/ts/default.aspx

Association of Pet Dog Trainers: Understanding
Training Equipment Options – Collars, Leashes and Crates.
http://www.apdt.com/petowners/choose/equipment.aspx

Karen Pryor Academy – find a great trainer. https://www.karenpryoracademy.com/find-a-trainer

Luck,
Laurie. (2010). A Surprising Look at Balanced Training.
http://smartdog.typepad.com/smart_dog/2010/04/a-surprising-look-at-balanced-training.html

Ludwig, Cindy. (2011). Clicker Training. What Is It?
http://animalinfo.com.au/fact_sheets/view/2/25/175/Clicker_Training_What_is_it

Ludwig,
Cindy. (2011). Positive Reinforcement Training. What Is It?
http://animalinfo.com.au/fact_sheets/view/2/25/177/What_is_Positive_Reinforcement_Training

San Francisco Academy for Dog Trainers: Academy-Certified Trainers. https://www.academyfordogtrainers.com/sc/Academy_Graduate_Referral_List.pdf

The Humane Society of the United States: Dog Collars: Which
Type is Best For Your Dog? (2010).
http://www.humanesociety.org/animals/dogs/tips/collars.html


VanArendonk Baugh, L. (2010).Should You Use No Reward Markers? Examining the Debate.
http://www.clickertraining.com/node/2848

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Did Someone Say Play?

Playing With Your Dog
Author, Jan Casey



It was really the
highlight of my weekend. We decided to have a little recreation time, something
that is too rare lately. Jim and I packed up the picnic supplies, my mom, some
towels, and Buzz, our adolescent golden retriever. It was time for Buzz to
experience the open water at Burgess
Falls
, after all, he
comes from a long line of hunting dogs who love to swim. He had been showing
interest in swimming every time we walked at Cane Creek Park, so we decided a more challenging
environment was just the thing Buzz needed. He had a great time playing
“splish-splash,” learning about slippery moss on rocks, and swimming when the
bottom disappeared. He slept most of the way home. It was great, but not the
highlight to which I refer.



No, the highlight came
after we got home. Buzz’s two favorite young people, Brian and Winston, came to
visit after we unpacked the car. My first thought was “Buzz will be way too
tired to play anymore today.” I could not have been more wrong. Jim and I, too
worn out from the earlier exercise, sat down to watch the threesome play.
Football, soccer, and water retrieval from the kiddie pool, all seem to be an
element of the game with each player taking a role – Buzz was running back,
Winston was place kicker, Brian was tackle. Yet there was no official structure
to any of the play, no rules, no penalties, just fun. The games ended when no
one could run any longer.



I felt more relaxed
watching them than I had in a while. It dawned on me that we dog owners who are
saddled with responsibilities and aging spend a great deal of time training our
dogs, worrying about whether they will impress our friends with their sits and
downs and tricks. Some of us participate in organized sports, where the
challenge to perform and bring home the ribbons and titles can take away a
great deal of the pleasure of just partnering with our canines. Maybe with all
the stresses of the current times – gas shortages, politics, and economic
crises – maybe it’s time to stop and just play. Including the furry,
four-legged family members adds an exciting new dimension.



For some, it’s hard to
think like a kid when you have passed that age chronologically. So, like me,
some of you may need some ideas to get you started. Several recent books have
been published by several of my favorite authors: Dr. Patricia McConnell/Karen
London and Pat Miller. The McConnell/London book is titled Play Together,
Stay together.
As stated in the description at Dogwise.com, this booklet
emphasizes the importance of play in maintaining a healthy relationship with
your pooch. Both physical and mental games are included to help those of us
lacking that creative gene, which obviously must have gone to other members of
our family. Pat Miller’s book, Play With Your Dog, establishes the
benefits, both behavioral and physical, of playing games with your dog. The
games in her book are a compilation of games submitted by trainers around the
country. I’ve got both books on my Christmas wish list.



So what games can we
play while we wait for Santa? There are plenty of standard games available. I
love to play hide and seek with my pups. Once they are occupied with other dog
interests, I go out of sight, then call them using an urgent, but happy “Pup,
Pup, Pup!” More often than not, I get a thundering herd of dogs seeking me out.
They have learned that finding Mom will be rewarded, either with a treat or a
game of ball or Frisbee. This is a great game indoors or out (well, maybe not
with a Frisbee as the reward inside). It not only puts their tracking skills to
work, it enhances any recall work you may be doing.



Tug is a favorite game
for all my dogs. Just be sure to follow the rules that are found at http://www.clickerlessons.com/tug.htm
. Maybe you can play a shell game with your dog by hiding a treat under one of
three cups, then shuffling them. Got an old neglected radio controlled car? The
terrier breeds will think they are in Heaven chasing one of these. How about
putting a toy under a box or behind a door?



The games you play will
only be limited by your ability to think and act like a child again. If that’s
a problem, take a moment to watch kids and dogs playing. You might be inspired.
Most of all, you might find yourself relaxed and smiling at a time when the
rest of the world is not.



Jan Casey is a
reward-based trainer in Florida
at Courteous Canine, Inc. www.courteouscanine.com
and owner of Smiles and Wags Pet Services
www.smilesandwags.com. Mrs.
Casey is a member of the Association of Animal
Behavior Professionals.
Mrs.
Casey is a columnist for the Cookeville,
Tennessee
Herald-Citizen Pet
Pages
and Kid's Korner .
This column was originally written for the Herald-Citizen www.herald-citizen.com.










10 Tips for Choosing a Shelter Dog


Thank you to clickertraining.com for this article. Sheila
Meet Your Match: Ten
Tips for Choosing a Shelter Dog
By KPCT on 10/05/2011


Filed
in



October is Adopt-a-Shelter-Dog Month! Dog
adoption is a wonderful thing. There are many dogs in shelters and rescue
organizations that will make wonderful lifelong companions. So how do you find
the best match for you and your family?



In
her book
Do
Over Dogs: Give Your Dog a Second Chance for a First Class Life
,
Pat Miller explains how
to conduct your own behavior
assessment to evaluate a prospective adoptee. Here are some of the steps to
follow as you evaluate a future canine family member:



[Excerpted
from
Do Over Dogs: Give Your Dog a Second Chance
for a First Class Life
]



1. Observe the dog in his kennel from a distance. Does he seem calm,
friendly, and relaxed; excitable and aroused; stressed and nervous; or timid
and fearful? What does he do when people or other dogs walk by?



2. Walk up to the kennel and stand sideways at the kennel door in a
neutral position.
Don’t talk to him or make eye contact as you stand sideways. Does
he come to the front of the kennel with a happy face and friendly wagging tail?
Charge to the front of the kennel barking aggressively? Slink to the back and
avoid eye contact? Stand or lie down quietly, looking at you?



3. Turn and face him in the kennel. Make direct eye contact, stare, and
don’t smile, but don’t actively threaten him. Is he happy and friendly? A
little worried? Very fearful? Does he stare back and growl or bark?



4. Kneel down and make happy talk. Is he still friendly? Less fearful?
More aroused or aggressive?



5. Have another person take him out of the kennel on-leash. Does he walk with
confidence, or does he have to be coaxed through doorways and across new
surfaces? Is he pulling ahead of the person walking him, or lagging far behind?
As he walks past other dogs does he try to greet them happily? Aggressively? Or
does he try to avoid other dogs altogether?



6. Take the dog to a separate room—preferably a relatively quiet room
with few distractions
. Remove the leash, sit on a chair, and let him explore for
several minutes, without trying to engage with him. Is he curious and
confident? Tentative and cautious? Excited and boisterous? Does he try to leave
the room?



7. Sit on a chair in the center of the room and solicit his
attention.
Does he come to you when you call him or does he ignore or avoid
you and continue to explore the room? Is he polite when he greets you? Does he
jump all over you? Does he seem fearful when you try to interact?



8. Put his leash back on and sit on the chair again. Stroke his back, his
far side, and touch, lift, tug on (gently!), and hold various parts of his body
– his tail, his ears, his feet. Does he enjoy or resist the handling? Get
excited or fearful?



9. Training. Without food at first, ask the dog to perform various behaviors
that he may already know, such as sit, shake, and lie down. Use common owner
body language cues (hand at your chest for a sit, pointing to or patting the
floor for down, offering your own hand for shake). Then try and get him to do
some behaviors he doesn’t know for a tasty food treat—sit, down (if he didn’t
do them for you without treats), or maybe a spin or twirl, where you lure him
in a circle to see if he’ll follow the treat. Does he know anything already?
Does he seem willing to try new things? Is he fearful of your attempts to
elicit new behaviors, or too stressed to even consider a treat?



10. Playtime! If the dog you’re assessing has been outgoing and friendly, try
normal play with him. If he has seemed cautious or fearful, play very gently.
See if he’ll chase a ball. Does he bring it back? If he shows no interest in a
ball, try a soft squeaky toy, and offer to play tug with a tug toy. If he won’t
play with toys, try running away from him and see if he’ll run after you, or
get down on the floor and invite him to play. If he’ll engage with you
lightheartedly, he’s playing, even if he doesn’t know how to play with toys. On
the other end of the scale, is he getting
too excited during play? Is
he biting at you, grabbing your clothes, jumping on you, perhaps even mounting
you? When you stop playing, hide the toy in your hand and fold your arms in
front of you. Does he stop what he’s doing or continue to interact
inappropriately with you?



It’s
a good idea to alert shelter or rescue staff members ahead of time that you
will be doing this assessment so that they know what to expect. Remember, this
assessment cannot tell you everything a dog will do in the future. It only
gives you a snapshot of what the dog did on one day, in one particular
environment in response to specific, limited stimuli.



You’ll find more tips on assessing, preparing
for, and bringing out the best in your adoption dog in
Do Over Dogs! Give Your Dog a Second Chance for a First Class Life
--
available
in the clickertraining.com store.





Saturday, October 8, 2011

How Smart are Dogs?

How smart are dogs?
Author, Bob McMillan

It’s a question we’re pretty smug about since we can drive to the store, read
labels, plunk the correct currency down, find our way home and open a can of dog food without breaking a sweat.

The dog just sprawls there on the couch.
He may drool when he hears the can opener. We don’t expect him to pass the time calculating quantum physics. We don’t expect a lot, really. He’s a dog, for goodness sakes. If he sits, heels, spits out your shoe on command and goes outside to use the bathroom, we figure we’ve got ourselves a keeper.

Truth is, we just don’t think about it much. When we do, “how smart” usually means: how good is my dog at keeping out of trouble and doing what I say? If we have a lot of time on our hands, we might wonder, can Bowser fetch me a beer from the fridge like that dog on television. Can he learn tricks?

But, have you ever wanted to know a little more about what’s going on inside that shaggy skull? Does he or she like us just because of our opposable thumbs and our taste in couches?

You’re in luck. Researchers these days are releasing new findings about our canine pals. Turns out, there’s a lot more going on in Fido’s mind than you might think. The trick is figuring out what it means to you and your dog.

Stanley Coren, a Canadian psychology professor and researcher with a series of books on dog intelligence and behavior, caused a stir in 1994 when he surveyed dog trainers and rated dog breeds onto how well they understand new commands and obey on the first command.

I wasn’t floored that my beagle landed at the bottom of the list. I was a
little miffed that my Irish wolfhound and Scottish deerhounds rated dead
average. A lot of other readers squawked at the results too. There was nothing “average” or sub-par about their Bull terrier, Pug or Borzoi, they protested.

But again, what was being tested? How well dogs obey us. Humans devised the test. I wonder how well we’d perform on a test, say, given by...dogs. Can we catch a whiff of a bacon sandwich dropped on the sidewalk last week? Can we hear a coin drop a quarter mile away? Can we see that cat hiding in the tree? At night? Are we stupid because we can’t? Luckily, most dogs are too gracious to snicker at us.

We’re different species. “Intelligence” is a slippery question. We have different but complimentary strengths and weaknesses. We’ve chosen to live together. It’s not the dog’s IQ that’s important to us, it’s the bond. How well do we like and understand each other from across the divide?

I didn’t seriously grapple with the intelligence question until ten years ago
when I got a giant hound. Bonding became more than academic when I realized if we didn’t connect fast, telling him to “come” or “heel” would be about as effective as telling a glacier to turn left. At ten weeks old, Cuchulain, my Scottish deerhound, was bigger than many adult dogs. I read. Voraciously.

But the real education came when I decided to let him live indoors with me. If I was going to have a dog, I wanted to get to know him well. We learned each other’s moods and habits. I learned to read his subtle changes in his
expressions and body language and he learned mine. He picked up a vocabulary of dozens of words like “no!” which he preferred to ignore, and “food” which made him dance.

Living with Cuchulain, I learned he was slyly manipulative, he learned fast what worked and what didn’t, and he had a sense of humor. He’d do things just to get a rise out of me ... and then grin. Friendship happened.

But light bulbs really came on for me with Finn, my Irish wolfhound, when I learned about reward-based training. Finn was even bigger than Cuchulain and solid as pile of ore. I took a tip from SeaWorld, where they train killer whales and dolphins. You can’t jerk the leash of a killer whale, at least not more than once.

Trainers use a toy clicker to precisely signal when the animal does what they want and reward it with food. Clicker training is now widely used in the dog world too.
What fascinates me about clicker training isn’t simply that the dog will sit
for a piece of cheese. It’s watching their intellect come alive.

One training clicker: $1.50. A bag of cheese cubes: $3. Watching your dog think: Priceless.

I now have three giant dogs who pay very close attention to me. If I’m not
fast enough giving a command, they’ll try something, anything, to show me
they’re thrilled to work for food. Want me to sit over here? How ‘bout if I
stand on three legs? Can I carry that bag of cheese for you?


It spills over from training to everyday companionship. Giant Finn cocks his head and listens when I talk to him. He doesn’t understand all the words, but he knows I’m communicating with him, and I’m the guy who makes fun things happen.

It worked so well on hunting dogs with a reputation for being “independent” that I tried reward-based training on the beagle. Beagles are not known as the rocket scientists of the canine crowd.

Bingo. Instant communication. I learned Sully’s not foggy. He’s merely overwhelmed by a world of exciting smells. But get his attention with something he likes (Sully would walk through fire for cheese), and the wheels turn. When I understood him, I respected him more and he thrived on the rapport.

How smart are dogs? The question, really, is: How smart are we? How much are we really seeing?


Bob McMillan is an editor and columnist with the Cookeville Herald-Citizen
newspaper and lives on a mountain with several giant hounds and wary cats.

This column was originally printed in the Herald-Citizen
in Cookeville, Tennessee.
Please visit http://www.herald-citizen.com/ for more information on the
newspaper. We thank the Herald-Citizen
staff for allowing FFBF
to re-print this piece.